Peer Review Process
Overview
Every manuscript submitted to a CSDI OpenResearch journal goes through editorial screening followed by double-blind peer review before a publication decision is made.
Stages
- Technical Check — an editor confirms the submission meets basic formatting and completeness requirements.
- Reviewer Assignment — the handling editor assigns one or more qualified reviewers.
- Peer Review — reviewers evaluate the manuscript's rigor, originality, and contribution, and submit a recommendation.
- Editorial Decision — the editor weighs reviewer input and issues a decision: Accept, Minor Revision, Major Revision, or Reject.
Confidentiality
Reviewer identities and their internal comments are never disclosed to authors. Authors receive a decision letter composed by the editor, which may draw on reviewer feedback without exposing raw reviewer notes or reviewer identity.